top of page
Search

Why Sarah J. Maas is the Queen of Romantasy (Yes, I have FEELINGS)

Nov 9
7 min read

(NO SPOILERS HERE! THIS POST IS SAFE TO READ!)


I have officially finished A Court of Splintered Harmony, and I would like to file a formal complaint against Sarah J. Maas for the emotional distress she continues to inflict upon me.


Will I recover? Probably.


Will I immediately read the next book? Obviously.


Because here's the thing: I have a complicated relationship with this book. I loved it, but I also spent a significant portion of it wondering whether every single character had collectively lost their ever-loving minds. At times, it felt less like I was reading an epic fantasy romance and more like I was watching an especially dramatic season of reality television.


The secrets! The questionable decisions! The drama! The moments when I wanted to reach through the pages, grab someone by the shoulders, and scream, WHAT ARE YOU DOING?!


Cauldron boil me, someone get these people a reunion episode and a licensed therapist. PLEASE!


And yet, despite all my frustration, I finished the book absolutely desperate for more, which got me thinking. How does Sarah J. Maas DO that? How does she create stories that leave us simultaneously furious, devastated, obsessed, and counting down the days until the next installment?


Well, my friends, I have some thoughts. Because love her books or not, I think there's a reason Sarah J. Maas has become such a defining voice in romantasy (I would argue she even CREATED the genre) and as both an avid fantasy reader and a romantasy author myself, I think there's a lot to learn from the way she tells stories.



She Makes Us Care About Characters Who Are Absolute Disasters


Let's start with the obvious.

Sarah J. Maas writes characters who are deeply, gloriously, spectacularly flawed.

They make terrible decisions. They keep secrets they absolutely should not keep. They hurt people they love. They let pride, fear, jealousy, and trauma dictate their actions.


Sometimes, as a reader, it's exhausting (looking at you, literally everyone in A Court of Splintered Harmony), but here's the thing: I still care about them. I care so much that their terrible decisions make me genuinely angry.


And isn't that the magic of it all?


It's easy to love a character who always does the right thing. It's much harder—and often much more rewarding—to love a character who makes mistakes, disappoints you, and still manages to earn your investment. Which brings me to...


NESTA. GOOOOO, NESTA!


I absolutely loved getting more of her in this book. She is such a fascinating character because she's not particularly interested in being likable. She's prickly, defensive, stubborn, and sometimes downright infuriating, but she's also strong, fiercely loyal, and capable of tremendous growth. Her journey reminds me that character development isn't about becoming perfect. It's about learning to confront the worst parts of ourselves and choosing to do better.


And judging by the behavior of certain other characters in this latest installment, there is PLENTY of growing left to do. I'm just saying.


She Understands That Romance Is About More Than Kissing


Don't get me wrong. I love a good romantic scene. Give me all the longing glances, the accidental touches, the dramatic declarations, and the slow burn that makes me want to throw my Kindle across the room.


But the best romances aren't built on physical attraction alone. They're built on emotional transformation. The characters have to challenge each other. They have to confront their fears, question their beliefs, and learn to trust someone when every instinct tells them not to. That's what makes a romance satisfying!


It's not just about two people falling in love. It's about watching them become people who are capable of loving each other, and SJM understands that better than almost anyone.


Take Feyre and Rhysand, for example. Their relationship didn't become meaningful simply because they were attracted to each other. It became meaningful because of everything they went through, everything they learned, and the ways they helped each other grow after their traumatic experiences.


And speaking of Feyre... can we talk about seeing her in her MOM ERA? I loved it. There's something so satisfying about watching a character we've followed through so much pain and uncertainty enter a completely different stage of life. Her story didn't stop just because she's found love or started a family. She's still growing, just navigating a new chapter. As a mom myself, I so appreciate that.


And as a writer, this is something I think about constantly. A romance shouldn't be the end of a character's development. It should only be part of it.


Which is especially relevant when you're writing two stubborn enemies who would rather argue than admit they might actually care about each other. Not that I know anything about that. (Ahem. Nova and Zeph.)


She Creates Worlds We Never Want to Leave


If someone offered me a little townhouse in Velaris, I'd be packing my bags before they finished the sentence. Preferably, it would be somewhere near a bookstore, with a view of the Sidra and perhaps a certain High Lord's decorating budget.


One of SJM's greatest strengths is her ability to make fictional places feel like somewhere we could actually live. Prythian isn't just a backdrop for the characters. It's a world with history, politics, traditions, rivalries, and secrets that stretch far beyond the events of any single book. That's what makes it so immersive. Every time we return, there's something new to discover.


It's one of the things I admire most about SJM's storytelling, and it's something I've been thinking about a lot while developing the Fatebound Realms, the fantasy world where The Stormbound Heir takes place. I don't want Drosmere to feel like a collection of castles, forests, and stormy streets. I want it to feel like a place with a past, where people have lived and loved and fought and made terrible decisions long before my main characters came along. A place that continues existing even when the reader closes the book.


That's when worldbuilding becomes something special, and in that, SJM is a standard we can all try to achieve.


She Knows the Power of Found Family


If there's one thing SJM knows how to do, it's make readers emotionally attached to a group of fictional people.


The Inner Circle is practically its own character at this point. Their friendships, loyalty, shared history, and ridiculous interactions make the world feel alive. When they're all getting along, everything's wonderful. Beautiful. Give me more.


But when they're NOT getting along? Well. Apparently we get A Court of Splintered Harmony. 😂


But even when the relationships are messy, there's something powerful about watching people choose each other. Found family resonates because it speaks to a universal desire: to belong somewhere. To have people who know your worst qualities and love you anyway. To find a place where you don't have to pretend to be someone else.


And when those relationships are tested, the emotional stakes become enormous. Suddenly we're not just worried about whether a character will survive the next battle. We're worried about whether the people we've grown to love will ever find their way back to each other.


She Plays the Long Game


This is probably the reason I'm currently experiencing so many conflicting emotions about A Court of Splintered Harmony.


SJM was blatant in her opening note that this is not a complete story. It really is just a tip of the iceberg. Or, more accurately, the first gust of wind before an absolutely catastrophic maelstrom.


We're standing at the beginning of a much larger arc, and I can already tell things are going to get MESSY. There are questions I need answered, relationships I need repaired, and characters I need to see make better decisions. Oh, and approximately seventeen conversations that desperately need to happen before someone starts another war. PLEASE!


But I'm frustrated because I'm invested, right?


I know these characters. I know what they're capable of. I know how far they've come. So when they start making choices that seem to undo that growth, it's maddening, but it also makes me wonder what SJM is setting up. Because we all know she has a talent for planting seeds that don't fully bloom until much later.


My favorite moment when I'm reading one of her books is when something I thought was a passing comment turns out to be MUCH more complicated. And suddenly I'm looking back at an earlier book thinking, HOW DID I NOT SEE THAT COMING?!


As an author, I have enormous respect for that kind of storytelling. It requires patience, planning, and a willingness to trust that readers will stick around long enough to see the payoff.


And apparently, I am exactly the kind of reader who will. Even while complaining loudly about it.


She Makes Us Feel EVERYTHING


At the end of the day, this is why I think Sarah J. Maas deserves her reputation as the queen of romantasy.


It's not because every book is perfect, not because every character is likable, and certainly not because I agree with every creative decision she makes. It's because her stories make me FEEL things.


Joy. Grief. Frustration. Hope. Anger. Excitement. Sometimes all within the same chapter.


I can spend an entire evening reading one of her books, close it at two in the morning, and then lie awake thinking about what just happened.


And isn't that what we want from a good story? We want to be transported somewhere else, to care about people who don't exist and experience something that stays with us long after we've turned the final page.


As a writer, that's what I aspire to create. My stories might look and sound different than her, but I want to create that same kind of feeling. That moment when a reader becomes so invested in a fictional world that it starts to feel real. When they laugh at the banter, cry over a betrayal, and spend the next three days thinking about a character's decisions. When they finish the book and immediately need to talk to someone about it.


Which, incidentally, is exactly why I'm writing this blog post.


So, Sarah J. Maas, We Need to Talk.


I loved A Court of Splintered Harmony. I also wanted to scream at it. Repeatedly.


I adored seeing more of Nesta, loved getting glimpses of Feyre navigating motherhood, and I am genuinely excited about where this next arc might take us. But I also need everyone to take a long, hard look at themselves and perhaps consider attending a few group therapy sessions before the next installment, because GOOD GRIEF.


And January? JANUARY CANNOT COME FAST ENOUGH.


I need answers. I need character growth. I need some of these people to sit down and have an actual adult conversation. And knowing Sarah J. Maas, I'll probably get approximately three answers and seventeen new questions.


Will I be annoyed? Probably.

Will I devour the next book anyway? ABSOLUTELY.


And that, my friends, is why she remains the queen of romantasy.


Now, I desperately need to know:


Have you finished A Court of Splintered Harmony? What did you think?


Are you Team Loved It, Team Frustrated Beyond Belief, or Team I Have No Idea How I Feel Yet?


And for my fellow SJM fans, what's the ONE thing you absolutely need answered in the next installment?


Let's discuss in the comments! Just please be mindful of spoilers for readers who haven't finished yet.


Until next time, happy reading!


— Ceara 🖤

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page